Though the DVD cover of
S&Man is extremely
misleading (it makes it look like a crappy slasher), rest assured that
the actual film is pretty damn brilliant, challenging and powerful. I
was surprised to find that director J.T. Petty (
The Burrowers,
Soft for Digging)
made this film and that I hadn’t heard of it sooner. Though it had a
festival run way back in 2006, the film wasn’t released on DVD stateside
until October 2010.
S&Man (aka
Sandman, not
S & M Man,
like I originally thought!) is a film that explores the seedier side of
horror that encompasses the “hardcore” mock-snuff films like the
August Underground or
Guinea Pig series that are infamous for their shock value and hyper-realism.
Set up like a documentary,
S&Man was originally
supposed to be a vehicle for Petty to do a film on a local peeping tom
from a suburb he grew up in, but this plan fell through when the man
refused to do the film. However, Petty still wanted to pursue doing a
film on voyeurism, so he turned to the underground horror world and
found three purveyors of low-brow horror films to feature.
First and probably the most well known is Fred Vogel of Toe Tag Pictures, creator of the
August Underground
series. Vogel is certainly not the originator of fake snuff films, but
over the years his extreme films have probably become the most
well-known. Featuring brutal violence on grainy film, stunts including
real bodily fluids (vomit, feces, you name it), graphic nudity and so
on, Vogel’s films, most of which he stars in, really do look like home
movies of serial killers.
The next filmmaker is the seemingly perpetually drunk, middle-aged
metalhead Bill Zebub, whose films usually feature busty women in
distress, some blood, and not much else. Zebub’s films aren’t really
fake snuff or as extreme like Vogel’s and come off as little more than
exploitation. He states he makes films for perverts and not much else,
which is pretty much echoed in all the scenes shown from his films. In
one sad scene he putters around a set in a bar for hours while one of
his actresses is forced to lie ass up in a spread-eagle position wearing
a thong, bikini top and not much else. The exasperated and bored look
on her face pretty much says it all!
The last filmmaker interviewed, Eric Rost (Erik Marcisak), is the
only fictional one, as Vogel and Zebub do exist in real life and you can
purchase their films. At first, Eric appears like any other horror
fan-boy with dreams of making it big with his own “vision” for horror
films. He shows up at a horror convention Petty is attending and gives
Petty his own horror films, called the
S&Man
series. The series is very voyeuristic, and features women being filmed
seemingly without their knowledge before they are kidnapped and killed.
The films look entirely realistic and Petty spends the documentary
trying to get more information from Eric, like if he can contact the
actresses that appeared in
S&Man, but Eric isn’t
very forthcoming. In fact, Eric won’t give Petty a straight answer on
whether he obtained consent from the women before stalking and filming
them. Petty soon becomes suspicious and thinks Eric may be a real snuff
filmmaker who is killing his victims.
In between talking with these three filmmakers, Petty interweaves
interviews with psychologists, a self-professed “scream queen” (can just
any woman that bares her boobs in a few crappy horror movies be
considered a “scream queen” nowadays?), and feminist author of
Men, Women and Chainsaws
Carol Clover (yay, one of my favorites! I adore this woman!). These
interviews add to the overall weight of the faux documentary, but the
most interesting scenes occur when Petty turns his camera on the three
filmmakers.
I found
S&Man to be a challenging film to sit
through at times, but the issues it addresses like voyeurism, gender,
exploitation of actresses and how this exploitation eerily mirrors the
exploitation of real-life victims, how far is too far, etc., etc. are
what ultimately makes it rewarding. If you are anything like me, you’ll
be equally parts repulsed and intrigued by Petty’s film, though in the
end it will hopefully make you think and question your own personal
limits.
Buy it on
Amazon!